About the review
|
|
Review
|
|
Agree with this review? |
Have an opinion and want to be known for it? Share your opinion directly with the musican and start earning your Reviewer Reputation by reviewing this song.
| 1 | Overall ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | Description |
| Though not good it could be worse. Nevertheless the track is sub-par with synthetic, uninspired sound and an unfinished quality. | ||
| 2 | Creativity ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | Description |
| The melody and the mix don't add much to one's average NES Super Mario soundtrack. The melody, obviously based on a Mario melody, is dull and uninspired. The track doesn't add much if anything to the well known melody. | ||
| 3 | Artistic License ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | Description |
| The main instrument (guitar/banjo/?) sounds very synthetic, but that's fine. In contrast to that the background synth sound becomes annoying very quickly. Drum samples appear to be of varying quality between bad and mediocre. | ||
| 4 | Arrangement ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | Description |
| Arrangement works fairly well. You can easily guess which melody the artist based his track on. Transitions are quite smooth. The mountain principle (start with a few instruments and add more and more over time) adds some spice to the arrangement. Nevertheless it is a bit cluttered and feels hurried and unfinished. | ||
| 5 | Sound Quality ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | Description |
| I guess the track is done using some sort of tracker (Modplug?) and some freely available samples. As it's difficult to produce anything halfway acceptable in terms of sound quality this track is already kind of an achievement. | ||
| 6 | Does it work as a piece of music ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | Description |
| Interestingly this track more or less works as a piece of music. I could actually imagine someone using a slightly modified/polished version of it for a simple game. | ||
Reviewer Stats
about these stats
| Total Reviews: | 18 |
| Total Passed: | 6 |
| Avg. Days to Review: | 0.2 |
Feedback | |
| Total (Unique): | 16 (12) |
| % Favorable Reviews: | 50% |
| Positive Feedback: | 14 |
| Negative Feedback: | 0 |
| Reputation Score: | 93.8% |
|
About these stats hide • Total Reviews - The total reviewed songs, regardless of review format • Total Passed - The total songs given to review that were skipped • Avg. Days to Review - The amount of time it takes to review a song in their Reviewer Queue • Total (Unique) - Total feedback given (# of unique artists giving feedback) • Favorable Reviews - % of reviews with feedback that the user gave an overall score of 4 or 5 stars • Positive Feedback - # of positive recommendations by the artist • Negative Feedback - # of negative recommendations by the artist • Reputation Score - Score based on positive, netural and negative recommendations |
Reviews For This Song
T.Kuusniemi
I wasn't quite expecting this even though I saw the title and the genre. T... Read review
hientau
Though not good it could be worse. Nevertheless the track is sub-par with s... Read review
I wasn't quite expecting this even though I saw the title and the genre. T... Read review
hientau
Though not good it could be worse. Nevertheless the track is sub-par with s... Read review
Also Reviewed
Blue Droplets
This track is okay production-wise, but lacks diversity. No climax, no effe...
Read
Recore Enquiem
This ambitious track uses lots of different patterns, instruments, unexpect...
Read
Fate - Orc Prison
A piece of suspense, mostly solid, but lacking in atmosphere and arrangemen...
Read
kira
Overall a solid track with some ununsual instrumentation and a story feelin...
Read
Jazz Thing
Reviewing this track is hard as it has some flaws production- and soundwise...
Read
This track is okay production-wise, but lacks diversity. No climax, no effe...
Read
Recore Enquiem
This ambitious track uses lots of different patterns, instruments, unexpect...
Read
Fate - Orc Prison
A piece of suspense, mostly solid, but lacking in atmosphere and arrangemen...
Read
kira
Overall a solid track with some ununsual instrumentation and a story feelin...
Read
Jazz Thing
Reviewing this track is hard as it has some flaws production- and soundwise...
Read
Beta Feedback
Do you have suggestions on how we can improve? Did you find something broken? (This site is in beta so you probably did)











There are no comments yet. Be the first person to comment.