About the review

Title: Do Dat Thang FT. PhillyBlunt2000
Listen online: 
 
 download add to playlist
Artist: King Tru
Genre: Urban/Hip-Hop: Hip-Hop/Rap
Reviewed by: Spectra on March 25, 2008 (All reviews by Spectra)

Review Feedback: 

King Tru gave Spectra positive feedback for this review.

Agree
 
Disagree

Review

Agree with this review?  
Have an opinion and want to be known for it? Share your opinion directly with the musican and start earning your Reviewer Reputation by reviewing this song.


1Overall Description
Very smoothly executed hip-hop. This is premium far as a club track or in a car with good subs, but less so for listening due to the extensive repetition of the chord progression (the same 3 or so chords are repeated through the entire song).
 
2Creativity Description
The first 4 seconds have a very obvious, almost too obvious; a 3 note ascending melody followed by an equally obvious descending one...yet the melody from 6-8 seconds is considerably more playful and original sounding which keeps the song from sounding far too "academic". The vibrato/detune on the saw-type lead is downright fantastic, it just gives the song this multi-tone feel and keeps it from sounding flat (a problem that plagues many hip-hop songs). Some nice little transitions, such as the reverse cymbal at 0:43 and the conga that comes in after it very much enhance the piece...but the fact the kick-drum essentially keeps the same beat the whole song hurts a lot far as originality and variation. Moving the kick and snare more would do wonders for this track rhythm-wise.
 
3Artistic LicenseDescription
I can't say I know enough about hip-hop or have heard enough of it to comment on this section very well, so I am skipping it.
 
4Arrangement Description
A bass line change and chord change that enters during the breakdowns, IE at 1:05, keeps this song from feeling like it only has one part.
However, it is, at best, a fairly weak excuse for not making a second melody on top of the first, for example. The song ends up seeming to bridge/transpose the melodies rather than alter them and/or add on significantly different second and third melodies.
 
5Sound Quality Description
Note, though, just because the song is weak in the arrangement department does not mean the sound quality is bad. In fact, this track is on par with anything AliZhen, for example, has produced in terms of production clarity and the instruments work very well together harmonically.
It is excellent not just far as the leads but the bassline, the careful mixing of the drop-bass and the kick...simply put it would sound right at home in any club or professional venue...well done.
 
6VocalsDescription
I don't know enough about hip-hop to comment on this well...but, from a musical perspective I will at least say everything is on rhythm, in tune, and very clear vocally...and sounds of comparable quality to what little rap I hear played commercially (since, admittedly, I rarely listen to hip-hop).
 
7Does it work as a piece of music Description
Excellently as a club track, barely pass-able as a listening track due to the several factors of repetitiveness and lack of evolving beat described above. It all averages out to what sounds like an unfinished but solid professional hip-hop track...the good news is the things that need to be fixed are little things such as editing bass-kicks and the only real tough thing, I'd guess, would be figuring out a new, significantly different-than-the-theme, second melody that sounds clear with everything else.
 
Comments
Mar 28 2008 6:31 pm
by roncli

While this is excellent in terms of production quality, I agree with Spectra, this is not on par with other real good songs in this genre, even when comparing to some others on this site (Herbal Crew comes to mind).



Mar 27 2008 9:11 pm
by Spectra

Although our approaches have some difference, I would like to note tom tOm made some good points...I agree if the "point" of this song were to be very commercially oriented and succeed for a short length of time, it would likely be a 4.5 of 5 simply due to the smoothness and clarity of the lyrics. Although I am picky and rating this is a complete production and you as a rap music producer not just a rapper...rather than just rating your singing ability... When I think of hip-hop, I think of artists like 2-Pac or Dr Dre who, although their song DO in fact keep a common theme, have those little variations...and I think it is fair to say I have proof through history that rap songs considered classic. The second melody/mood in "California Love", for example, I still believe is part of why it's become a classic and not just a top 40 song for a month or so, same for the Fresh Prince's "Summertime" or virtually any of Run DMC's songs. Even "Baby Got Back" had separate variations: the brass section, the turntablism, the conga rolls, the cuts in the beat...sure the lyrics were killer, but there were several other elements that kept it popular. Note I agree with Tom Tom none of these song's are like jazz and I never intended to imply rap variation should be like jazz (which is part of why I said 2 main melodies as opposed to, say, 6+ melodies and 12+ chords that are in most jazz songs)... But at the same time I think there should be a happy medium IE rap shouldn't be that much more repetitive than, say, rock music...at least if it intends on becoming classic. That being said, again, this song is VERY close to being a 4, it's not on the low side of 3 but on the high side.



Mar 27 2008 12:36 pm
by Tom tOM

I disagree with part of this review, not to say that Spectra has written a bad review as it is obvious he has put in a lot of time and effort into it. But I think Spectra doesn't understand vocal music. No one enjoys a repetitive song, but at the same time, vocal music like hip-hop, needs a simple background so not to take the focus off the lyrics. Which is what hip-hop music is all about, the lyrics. You can not have someone rapping over a jazz song too well for example, because the lyrics and the horn/piano solos would clutter each other. They each need their own space to be heard. And unfortunately Spectra has not made an in-depth analysis of the made point of this kind of music i.e. the lyrics. The rapping delivery and flow is excellent King Tru, you are very talented and the sound quality is outstanding! What equipment did you record those vocals on? Probably if you didn't want your song just to be commercially orientated, and you wanted the listeners to play your song over and over and not get bored quickly, then the extra advice Spectra has given is very useful.



Mar 25 2008 9:41 pm
by King Tru

Thank you very much for the in depth review and honest points, I appreciate it very much! I agree with you on all points, the instrumental would have flourished a loy more if there was a beat break and then maybe a harder basline to bring back in the beat...or something like that. Thanks