About the review
|
|
Review
|
|
Agree with this review?   |
Have an opinion and want to be known for it? Share your opinion directly with the musican and start earning your Reviewer Reputation by reviewing this song.
| 1 | Overall   | Description |
| Sloppily made "battle" tune that could have benefitted from a total overhaul. | ||
| 2 | Creativity | Description |
| The song is only 47 seconds long, and although there is naturally very little repetition throughout, most of the ideas featured herein sound a bit too arbitrary to be the result of much forethought. A plus for the apparent attempt to create a recognisable melody, however. | ||
| 3 | Artistic License | Description |
| If this is a battle tune, then how do the other songs sound? Although the rhythm is hectic enough to fit with the hectic feel of a battle, the tune itself sounds far too "happy" to evoke much of that battle feeling. | ||
| 4 | Arrangement | Description |
| Well, the arrangement does stay within the boundaries of harmony, but only just. The sample playing at 0:17 is completely out of tune with the rest of the arrangement, though, and sounds very jarring. Also, the song has no real progression whatsoever. I am aware that it's composed to be a backing track, but it could still have slight fluctuations in intensity throughout. In addition the song just fades out and ends with no real feeling of closure. | ||
| 5 | Sound Quality | Description |
| This is obviously a tracked song, and features not only 8-bit tracker samples, but 8-bit samples of extremely low quality. Every sample features a high amount of hiss, and absolutely no depth to the bass. If the composer wants to keep the file size down to an absolute minimum - may I suggest ownloading a chip tune with decent sound to it, and using those samples instead? | ||
| 6 | Does it work as a piece of music | Description |
| No. I'm sorry to say this, but this song sounds very sloppy. I don't think I'm far off the mark when I say that the composer couldn't possibly have worked very long on this nor put his best efforts into it. My best advice would have to be to choose better samples and do another try - on the up side, it can probably only go upwards from here! :) | ||
Reviewer Stats
about these stats
| Total Reviews: | 58 |
| Total Passed: | 14 |
| Avg. Days to Review: | 0.5 |
Feedback | |
| Total (Unique): | 47 (32) |
| % Favorable Reviews: | 44.68% |
| Positive Feedback: | 45 |
| Negative Feedback: | 0 |
| Reputation Score: | 97.9% |
|
About these stats hide • Total Reviews - The total reviewed songs, regardless of review format • Total Passed - The total songs given to review that were skipped • Avg. Days to Review - The amount of time it takes to review a song in their Reviewer Queue • Total (Unique) - Total feedback given (# of unique artists giving feedback) • Favorable Reviews - % of reviews with feedback that the user gave an overall score of 4 or 5 stars • Positive Feedback - # of positive recommendations by the artist • Negative Feedback - # of negative recommendations by the artist • Reputation Score - Score based on positive, netural and negative recommendations |
Reviews For This Song
VOiD
Sloppily made "battle" tune that could have benefitted from a total overhau... Read review
Subatomic
Very poor effort making 8-bit music... Read review
TiLT
I'm always happy to see people compose music for computer games, as it's ... Read review
roncli
A poor attempt at creating old-style console game music. To improve, first... Read review
c0d3h4x0r
This sounds like out-of-tune music from an old Atari game.... Read review
Sloppily made "battle" tune that could have benefitted from a total overhau... Read review
Subatomic
Very poor effort making 8-bit music... Read review
TiLT
I'm always happy to see people compose music for computer games, as it's ... Read review
roncli
A poor attempt at creating old-style console game music. To improve, first... Read review
c0d3h4x0r
This sounds like out-of-tune music from an old Atari game.... Read review
Also Reviewed
Technicolor (Part 2)
Solid piece of melodic ambient synthpop executed with great focus and atten...
Read
Think
A nice, dreamy little number with a subdued yet airy atmosphere here. Unint...
Read
Empty Pieces
With a moody opening featuring some classic dialogue from the moon landing,...
Read
To Be Frank
Some gorgerous electric piano chords and a wicked synth bass line starts of...
Read
Shuffle on down the Rhodes
Here is a great, no nonsense, thorougly funky piece of jazz-rock fusion in ...
Read
Solid piece of melodic ambient synthpop executed with great focus and atten...
Read
Think
A nice, dreamy little number with a subdued yet airy atmosphere here. Unint...
Read
Empty Pieces
With a moody opening featuring some classic dialogue from the moon landing,...
Read
To Be Frank
Some gorgerous electric piano chords and a wicked synth bass line starts of...
Read
Shuffle on down the Rhodes
Here is a great, no nonsense, thorougly funky piece of jazz-rock fusion in ...
Read
Beta Feedback
Do you have suggestions on how we can improve? Did you find something broken? (This site is in beta so you probably did)
There are no comments yet. Be the first person to comment.