About the review
|
|
Review
|
|
Agree with this review?   |
Have an opinion and want to be known for it? Share your opinion directly with the musican and start earning your Reviewer Reputation by reviewing this song.
| 1 | Overall   | Description |
| While it feels that the author tried to put a lot of emotions into this one, it's not catchy. During all track we hear the same piano, bass, drums and pad. And, unfortunately, their sound is not good. The melody is changing too much - which makes it not to stick in mind. One of the genre stated for this song is not true either. It's not an ambient. | ||
| 2 | Creativity | Description |
| Unfortunately this track is not catchy. Through the whole 4:40 mins of a track all the same piano goes. The melody of it is changing however, but that does not save it. It needs to go off for some time, then return back. But not to be played during all the track. | ||
| 3 | Artistic License | Description |
| While it seems that the author tried to put much emotions in this production - things like instruments does not seem to work well together. For example bass is not fits quite well with the piano. | ||
| 4 | Arrangement | Description |
| The arrangement is not done well - for example transitions are not very noticable and do not stick in memory, also piano is panned to the left channel too much making the right one to feel emptier. | ||
| 5 | Sound Quality | Description |
| You can hear each instrument clearly, however the quality of them makes you wish for a better one. In a meaning that they sound like they were taken from some MIDI soundbank. The info placed in the track's mp3 tags states that it was made in 2001 - but the fact is - a software that gives better sound was available. | ||
| 6 | Does it work as a piece of music | Description |
| The production is constantly changing (too much even), but instruments do not. This makes for a dull track that does not stick to your mind. And given melody is not catchy. | ||
Reviewer Stats
about these stats
| Total Reviews: | 2 |
| Total Passed: | 0 |
| Avg. Days to Review: | 0 |
Feedback | |
| Total (Unique): | 2 (2) |
| % Favorable Reviews: | 50% |
| Positive Feedback: | 1 |
| Negative Feedback: | 0 |
| Reputation Score: | 75% |
|
About these stats hide • Total Reviews - The total reviewed songs, regardless of review format • Total Passed - The total songs given to review that were skipped • Avg. Days to Review - The amount of time it takes to review a song in their Reviewer Queue • Total (Unique) - Total feedback given (# of unique artists giving feedback) • Favorable Reviews - % of reviews with feedback that the user gave an overall score of 4 or 5 stars • Positive Feedback - # of positive recommendations by the artist • Negative Feedback - # of negative recommendations by the artist • Reputation Score - Score based on positive, netural and negative recommendations |
Reviews For This Song
roncli
Overall, a moderately inspiring pop-ish tune that relies on the piano to dr... Read review
Fredrik Cole
This piece of music is very reminesque of notes and styles I used myself wh... Read review
DJ. Jessie
Here is a nice melody and a good idea, sadly it falls a bit short in ideas ... Read review
Goor00
A nice melodic track with high potential which would deserve to be ported (... Read review
skyway
While it feels that the author tried to put a lot of emotions into this one... Read review
Overall, a moderately inspiring pop-ish tune that relies on the piano to dr... Read review
Fredrik Cole
This piece of music is very reminesque of notes and styles I used myself wh... Read review
DJ. Jessie
Here is a nice melody and a good idea, sadly it falls a bit short in ideas ... Read review
Goor00
A nice melodic track with high potential which would deserve to be ported (... Read review
skyway
While it feels that the author tried to put a lot of emotions into this one... Read review
Also Reviewed
New June Day
While it feels that the author tried to put a lot of emotions into this one...
Read
Outgate - Take Me Back (2007 mix)
Though it's understandable that such is the progressive style - a repetitiv...
Read
While it feels that the author tried to put a lot of emotions into this one...
Read
Outgate - Take Me Back (2007 mix)
Though it's understandable that such is the progressive style - a repetitiv...
Read
Beta Feedback
Do you have suggestions on how we can improve? Did you find something broken? (This site is in beta so you probably did)
There are no comments yet. Be the first person to comment.