About the review
|
|
Review
|
|
Agree with this review?   |
Have an opinion and want to be known for it? Share your opinion directly with the musican and start earning your Reviewer Reputation by reviewing this song.
| 1 | Overall   | Description |
| This is a disturbing soundscape in itself, it has good potential but lacks layers to fully function on its own. | ||
| 2 | Creativity | Description |
| The creation is very interesting in itself, but not really fulfilling. That creative thinking has been pushed well beyond borders of normal musical thinking is absolutley evident, although it SHOULD touch some of the aspects that say "music" as well, not just "fx". | ||
| 3 | Artistic License | Description |
| The artist does not push any limits of this piece; He merely lays out a direction for it to follow with more (and much needed) layers of sound. I have done something like this myself (the fx-part only), thought it worked but when I added 2 addidional layers; Namely spoken words and an abstract bassline it suddenly worked as music. This track still has ways to go, as it's perhaps only thirdway done yet, perhaps halfway. | ||
| 4 | Arrangement | Description |
| It's divided in two parts with little coherence in the latter. Although probably mathematically logical, it just feels random. Not to bore you with that "MORE LAYERS"-theme of mine, but I simply have to press that. :) | ||
| 5 | Sound Quality | Description |
| It may come short as a musical piece, but it sounds good. | ||
| 6 | Does it work as a piece of music | Description |
| It can be noted as a well made (and long playing) effect, but as music? No, not yet. Give it another spin in the grinder, mah man. Try some random musical elements just for fun, play it live for the duration of the track and see how it fits. | ||
Reviewer Stats
about these stats
| Total Reviews: | 30 |
| Total Passed: | 2 |
| Avg. Days to Review: | 0.3 |
Feedback | |
| Total (Unique): | 27 (17) |
| % Favorable Reviews: | 55.56% |
| Positive Feedback: | 25 |
| Negative Feedback: | 0 |
| Reputation Score: | 96.3% |
|
About these stats hide • Total Reviews - The total reviewed songs, regardless of review format • Total Passed - The total songs given to review that were skipped • Avg. Days to Review - The amount of time it takes to review a song in their Reviewer Queue • Total (Unique) - Total feedback given (# of unique artists giving feedback) • Favorable Reviews - % of reviews with feedback that the user gave an overall score of 4 or 5 stars • Positive Feedback - # of positive recommendations by the artist • Negative Feedback - # of negative recommendations by the artist • Reputation Score - Score based on positive, netural and negative recommendations |
Reviews For This Song
thekhin
This is a disturbing soundscape in itself, it has good potential but lacks ... Read review
roncli
A two-part experiment in noise and Renoise. The first part has an unsteady... Read review
This is a disturbing soundscape in itself, it has good potential but lacks ... Read review
roncli
A two-part experiment in noise and Renoise. The first part has an unsteady... Read review
Also Reviewed
Entranced (or what happens when I try to do trance)
I really liked the whole 'feel' of this track, not by any means breaking ne...
Read
Razor
This track is god damned brilliant!!! Very good work on the arrangement thi...
Read
6¶wÎ¥Ðe¥9¨¿
This is a disturbing soundscape in itself, it has good potential but lacks ...
Read
Blood And Oil
For its usage, this track delivers very well but have a couple of flaws tha...
Read
Shades
A very nice OHC, that's for sure! It'd be my top vote in any count. :) Also...
Read
I really liked the whole 'feel' of this track, not by any means breaking ne...
Read
Razor
This track is god damned brilliant!!! Very good work on the arrangement thi...
Read
6¶wÎ¥Ðe¥9¨¿
This is a disturbing soundscape in itself, it has good potential but lacks ...
Read
Blood And Oil
For its usage, this track delivers very well but have a couple of flaws tha...
Read
Shades
A very nice OHC, that's for sure! It'd be my top vote in any count. :) Also...
Read
Beta Feedback
Do you have suggestions on how we can improve? Did you find something broken? (This site is in beta so you probably did)
There are no comments yet. Be the first person to comment.